Types of Christmas trees: how to choose the best one
The best real Christmas tree is the one that fits how you decorate and what's sold near you. If you want needles that stay on, look at the true firs (Fraser, noble, Nordmann, Canaan). For the classic Christmas smell, balsam fir. For heavy ornaments, stiff branches like noble fir, Scotch pine or blue spruce. Below, 16 real trees side by side, every rating from university extension services, plus what grows where you live.
Start with your question
What types of real Christmas trees are there?
Read moreShow less
Firs (the genus Abies) include Fraser, balsam, noble, Canaan, Nordmann, concolor and grand fir. Pines include Scotch, eastern white and Virginia pine. Spruces include Colorado blue, white and Norway spruce. Douglas fir belongs to Pseudotsuga, so the Morton Arboretum and UW-Madison Extension both point out it isn't a true fir. Warm southern farms grow trees that handle heat, like Leyland cypress and eastern red cedar (NC State Extension, Clemson HGIC), and eastern red cedar is a juniper.
How do the tree types compare?
| Tree | Needle retention | Fragrance | Branches | Needles | Color | Shape | Grown in |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Fraser fir Abies fraseri | Good to excellent (sources disagree) | Strong | Medium to stiff (sources disagree) | Soft | Dark green, silvery underneath | Conical, with room between branches for ornaments | North Carolina mountains; also Michigan, Wisconsin, Quebec |
| Douglas fir Pseudotsuga menziesii | Good | Strong | Flexible to medium (sources disagree) | Soft | Blue-green to dark green | Full and naturally cone shaped | Oregon and Washington; also British Columbia, North Carolina mountains |
| Noble fir Abies procera | Excellent | Moderate | Stiff | Medium | Blue-green to dark green, silvery underneath | Upswept branches with open layers | Western Oregon and Washington |
| Balsam fir Abies balsamea | Good to excellent (sources disagree) | Strong | Flexible to medium (sources disagree) | Soft | Dark green | Narrow pyramid, good for tight spaces | New England, New York, the Great Lakes, Quebec and Atlantic Canada |
| Colorado blue spruce Picea pungens | Poor to good (sources disagree) | Moderate | Stiff | Sharp | Blue-gray to silvery blue | Symmetrical, classic cone | The Rockies, plus north central and northeastern states |
| Canaan fir Abies balsamea var. phanerolepis | Excellent | Light to strong (sources disagree) | Medium to stiff (sources disagree) | Soft | Dark green, silvery underneath | Uniform, dense pyramid | The Midwest and Northeast, where soil is too wet for Fraser fir |
| Nordmann fir Abies nordmanniana | Excellent | Not rated by our sources | Stiff | Soft | Glossy dark green, silvery underneath | Dense, branches often to the ground | Most popular tree in Europe; planted in the Pacific Northwest |
| Concolor fir Abies concolor | Good to excellent (sources disagree) | Light to strong (sources disagree) | Flexible to stiff (sources disagree) | Soft to sharp (sources disagree) | Blue-green to silvery | Sources differ: airy and open, or a dense pyramid | Michigan and the Northeast; grown in North Carolina with mixed success |
| Grand fir Abies grandis | Not rated by our sources | Strong | Not rated by our sources | Sharp | Glossy dark green | Conical, needles in flat sprays | Grown commercially in its native Pacific Northwest and British Columbia |
| Scotch pine Pinus sylvestris | Good to excellent (sources disagree) | Moderate | Stiff | Medium | Dark green to blue-green | Dense when sheared, open with room for ornaments | Midwest and eastern farms; the Prairies |
| Eastern white pine Pinus strobus | Good to excellent (sources disagree) | Light to strong (sources disagree) | Flexible to medium (sources disagree) | Soft | Soft blue-green | Very full when sheared | Across its native range, from the Carolinas to New England |
| Virginia pine Pinus virginiana | Poor to excellent (sources disagree) | Moderate to strong (sources disagree) | Stiff | Not rated by our sources | Dark green | Dense, shaped by shearing | The South: the top choose-and-cut tree in eastern North Carolina |
| White spruce Picea glauca | Fair | Unpleasant when crushed | Medium to stiff (sources disagree) | Medium | Green to blue-green | Good natural shape | Alaska, the Great Lakes and the Prairies |
| Norway spruce Picea abies | Good | Moderate | Medium | Medium | Shiny dark green | Conical | The Northeast and Great Lakes |
| Leyland cypress × Hesperotropsis leylandii | Excellent | Light | Flexible | Soft | Dark green to gray-green | Dense, natural shape | Every southern state, mostly sold choose-and-cut |
| Eastern red cedar Juniperus virginiana | Fair | Strong | Flexible | Sharp | Dark green, varies a lot | Dense and fine textured | The South, sold locally |
Every rating comes from extension services such as Michigan State University, Penn State, Iowa State, Illinois, Virginia Tech and the Morton Arboretum. When they disagree, the chart shows the range ("good to excellent") instead of picking a side, and a trait no source rates says so.
Which Christmas tree lasts the longest?
Read moreShow less
UW-Madison Extension says true firs keep their needles longest. Washington State University says a watered noble fir can last about eight weeks, and Nordmann fir lasted about three months in one test. Scotch pine is the odd one out among pines: Illinois Extension and Iowa State say its needles stay on even when it dries, though a dry tree still needs water to stay safe.
At the short end, Penn State says a blue spruce that dries out even once drops many needles, and eastern red cedar dries quickly and may last only two to three weeks (Illinois Extension, NC State). Whatever you pick, our guide to keeping a real tree fresh is what makes it last.
Which Christmas tree smells the best?
Read moreShow less
Michigan State calls balsam fir the tree people pick for its strong Christmas tree scent, and the Morton Arboretum agrees. Clemson calls Fraser fir's fragrance exceptional and long lasting, and Illinois puts Douglas fir among the best aromas when its needles are crushed. Eastern red cedar is very strongly aromatic too (Clemson, Iowa State).
Concolor fir is the one that smells like oranges or lemons: Michigan State, Penn State, Cornell and the Morton Arboretum all describe a citrus scent from crushed needles, though NC State's plant database calls it only slight. White spruce is the tree to sniff before you buy: several extension services say its crushed needles smell unpleasant.
Which tree holds heavy ornaments?
Read moreShow less
Penn State says blue spruce holds the heaviest ornaments and Scotch pine holds heavy ones with ease. Illinois calls noble fir's short, stiff branches good for heavier ornaments. NC State, UW-Madison and Iowa State call Fraser fir's branches stiff, while Penn State says moderately stiff, so skip your heaviest glass on its tips. For Douglas fir, UW-Madison and Iowa State say the branches are less stiff and better with lighter ornaments.
Which tree is best with kids and pets?
Read moreShow less
UW-Madison, Penn State and NC State all warn about blue spruce's sharp needles around small children. The ASPCA suggests anchoring the tree so it can't tip and covering the stand water, which can grow bacteria that upset a pet's stomach. More on needles, tree water and other holiday plants in our guide to Christmas plants and pets.
What's the difference between a fir, a pine and a spruce?
Read moreShow less
Penn State describes Fraser fir's needles as soft and flat. NC State and Clemson describe eastern white pine's long needles in bundles of five. Spruce needles are short and stiff, and blue spruce's sharp tips are why Penn State suggests other trees for homes with small children.
Which Christmas trees are sold where you live?
More than 14.5 million Christmas trees were cut in the US in 2022 (USDA Economic Research Service, Iowa State's Ag Marketing Resource Center). In Canada, Agriculture and Agri-Food Canada counted Quebec, Nova Scotia and New Brunswick as the source of 96% of exported trees in 2024. Here's what's common in each region, and why:
United States
Northeast
Native balsam fir likes the cool, moist climate of New England, New York and Pennsylvania. Farms also grow Fraser and Douglas fir, pines and spruces.
Balsam fir, Fraser fir, Douglas fir, Concolor fir, Eastern white pine, Scotch pine, Colorado blue spruce, Canaan fir, Norway spruce
Southeast
Fraser fir needs cool mountain summers, so it grows in the high Appalachians. Lower and warmer areas grow heat-tolerant pines, cedars and cypresses.
Fraser fir, Virginia pine, Eastern red cedar, Leyland cypress, Eastern white pine
Midwest and Great Lakes
Cold winters suit native balsam fir, white spruce and white pine. Fraser and Canaan fir are planted for needle retention, and Scotch pine is the long-time favorite.
Fraser fir, Balsam fir, Canaan fir, Scotch pine, Eastern white pine, Colorado blue spruce, Douglas fir, Concolor fir, White spruce, Norway spruce
Mountain West
Most trees on Utah lots are grown in Oregon and Washington. Local farms are smaller, and their trees are fresher because they are cut closer to Christmas.
Southwest
New Mexico suggests blue spruce, Douglas fir and Scotch pine for its tree farms, plus piñon, Afghan pine and Arizona cypress in the warmer south.
Pacific Northwest
Noble and Douglas fir are native here, and the mild, wet climate suits them. Oregon is the top Christmas tree state in the US.
Alaska and Hawaii
Many Alaskans cut a local white or black spruce. Hawaii's cut trees arrive by ship from the Pacific Northwest.
Canada
Atlantic provinces
Cool, moist winters suit balsam fir. Nova Scotia and New Brunswick ship about a third of Canada's exported trees.
Quebec
Native balsam fir is the most grown tree, then Fraser fir. Quebec ships most of Canada's exported Christmas trees, nearly all to the US.
Ontario
Ontario has more Christmas tree farms than any other province. Balsam fir is native across the north.
The Prairies
Scotch pine grows fast in prairie conditions; balsam fir and white spruce are grown too. Farms are few, so many trees come from eastern Canada, BC, Oregon and Washington.
British Columbia
Douglas fir, native to the province, is the main tree. Farms also grow grand, noble and concolor fir and pines.
Douglas fir, Grand fir, Noble fir, Concolor fir, Scotch pine, Eastern white pine
Every tree type, one by one
The six trees people search for most have their own page with a full tree card. The rest are here, with a link where there's more.
Fraser fir
Soft, dark green needles with silvery undersides, a strong scent and needles that hold on. The signature tree of the North Carolina mountains. Read the Fraser fir guide.
Douglas fir
Soft needles and a sweet scent when crushed, on branches best for lighter ornaments. Not a true fir. The main tree of Oregon, Washington and British Columbia. Read the Douglas fir guide.
Noble fir
Stiff, layered branches made for heavy ornaments and excellent needle retention. Grown in western Oregon and Washington. Read the noble fir guide.
Balsam fir
The classic Christmas scent in a narrow shape that fits tight spaces. Native to the Northeast and most of Canada. Read the balsam fir guide.
Colorado blue spruce
Silvery blue, symmetrical and sturdy, with sharp needles. Keep the stand full: it sheds fast once dry. Read the Colorado blue spruce guide.
Canaan fir
A Fraser fir look-alike that growers plant where the soil is too wet for Fraser. Excellent needle retention. Read the Canaan fir guide.
Nordmann fir
Europe's most popular Christmas tree: glossy dark green, dense and long lasting (Michigan State, NC State). In North America it's planted mostly in the Pacific Northwest. No trusted source rates its scent.
Concolor fir
Blue-green to silvery needles that smell of citrus when crushed. Sources split on its branches and shape, so check the tree in person (Penn State, Morton Arboretum).
Grand fir
A very fragrant western fir with glossy needles and a citrus scent when crushed (NC State, Illinois). Its needle retention and branches aren't rated by our sources.
Scotch pine
The long-time favorite: stiff branches for heavy ornaments and needles that stay on even when dry (Clemson, Penn State). The needles are stiffer than a fir's.
Eastern white pine
Long, soft, blue-green needles and, for most sources, a light scent, on flexible branches for light ornaments. It wilts visibly if it runs short of water (Clemson, NC State).
Virginia pine
A southern favorite with strong branches for heavy ornaments, shaped by shearing. Sources disagree sharply on how well it holds needles: Clemson says excellent, Virginia Tech says fair to very poor (Clemson, Virginia Tech).
White spruce
Stiff branches and good color, but fair needle retention and needles that smell unpleasant when crushed (Iowa State, Illinois). Many Alaskans cut a local one.
Norway spruce
Shiny dark green and conical. It holds needles well only when cut fresh and kept watered (NC State, Morton Arboretum).
Leyland cypress
A soft, lightly scented southern tree on flexible branches, mostly sold choose-and-cut. It drinks a lot, so check the water at least twice a day (Clemson, NC State).
Eastern red cedar
The traditional southern tree: very fragrant and prickly, on limber branches. It dries quickly, so keep the stand full (Clemson, NC State).
Frequently asked questions (FAQ)
Which Christmas tree doesn't shed?
Every real tree drops some needles, and a dry one drops the most. The ones that hold on best are the true firs with excellent ratings (noble, Nordmann, Canaan and, for most sources, Fraser) and Scotch pine. Keeping the stand full matters more than the species; see how to keep a real tree fresh.
Which Christmas tree smells like oranges?
Concolor fir. Michigan State, Penn State, Cornell and the Morton Arboretum describe a citrus scent, like orange or lemon, when you crush a needle. Grand fir has a citrus note too.
What's the best Christmas tree for a small space?
Balsam fir grows in a narrow pyramid, and Cornell calls it good for tight spaces. The Morton Arboretum and NC State also describe its narrow shape.
Should I get a cut tree or a potted one?
That depends on whether you want to plant it afterward. Our cut or potted tree guide compares the two honestly. For fun facts and a few myths, see Christmas tree facts.
Sources
- Christmas Tree Species Guide : Michigan State University Extension
- Selection and Care of Cut Christmas Trees : Penn State Extension
- Tips for Selection and Care of Cut Christmas Trees : Penn State Extension (updated September 2025)
- Christmas Tree Species : NC State Extension (revised January 2019)
- Leyland Cypress : NC State Extension
- Selecting a Christmas Tree : Clemson Cooperative Extension, Home and Garden Information Center (revised November 2019)
- What types of Christmas trees are available? : Iowa State University Extension and Outreach
- Choosing the Right Christmas Tree : UW-Madison Extension (December 2024)
- Tree Species : University of Illinois Extension
- Christmas Tree Guide : Cornell Cooperative Extension, Monroe County (2024)
- Christmas tree species characteristics, Table 2 : Virginia Cooperative Extension
- Selecting the perfect Christmas tree : The Morton Arboretum
- Douglas-fir, Balsam fir and White fir : The Morton Arboretum
- Nordmann fir and Grand fir : NC State Extension Gardener Plant Toolbox
- Ask Mr. Christmas Tree : Washington State Magazine, Washington State University (October 2013)
- Holiday Safety Tips : ASPCA
- Christmas trees, Charts of Note : USDA Economic Research Service (December 2024)
- Christmas Trees : Ag Marketing Resource Center, Iowa State University (revised February 2024)
- Statistical Overview of the Canadian Ornamental Industry, 2024 : Agriculture and Agri-Food Canada